South Africa: the reading crisis, mother tongue schooling and the BELA Act test
Objective
Assess South Africa's foundational reading crisis using the PIRLS 2021 results and the first Funda Uphumelele National Survey (FUNS) of November 2025, and evaluate whether mother tongue-based bilingual education and the Basic Education Laws Amendment (BELA) Act of 2024 can close the gap.
Methodology
Review of the PIRLS 2021 results, the FUNS survey released in November 2025 by the Department of Basic Education, the Thrive by Five Index 2024, Department of Basic Education policy documents on mother tongue-based bilingual education, and academic and civil society analysis from 2025 and 2026. Figures were cross-checked across sources.
Findings
South Africa's reading crisis is severe and persistent. In PIRLS 2021, 81 per cent of Grade 4 learners could not read for meaning, placing the country last out of 57 participating countries.
The Funda Uphumelele National Survey (FUNS), released in November 2025, gives the first comprehensive picture of early-grade reading in Grades 1 to 4 across all 11 official languages: only about 30 per cent of Grade 3 learners are reading at the expected level in home language, and by Grade 4 fewer than half have reached the Grade 3 home language benchmark.
The Thrive by Five Index 2024 found only 42 per cent of children entering Grade R and Grade 1 are on track in early learning. A central cause is language: many learners switch abruptly from home language to English as the language of learning and teaching in Grade 4, a disruption at a critical stage of development.
The Department of Basic Education is rolling out Mother Tongue-based Bilingual Education (MTbBE) to extend home-language instruction, and the BELA Act of 2024, especially clauses 4 and 5 on language policy and admissions, sparked intense contention within the Government of National Unity.
President Cyril Ramaphosa promised in 2019 that every ten-year-old would read for meaning by 2030, but FUNS shows the country is far from that target. The Right to Read campaign, a broad civil society alliance, is calling for binding national reading regulations for the Foundation Phase, arguing that measurement without follow-through changes little.
The evidence is that time alone will not resolve the crisis: targeted mother tongue instruction, teacher development and accountability are needed together.
Key Assumptions
- •PIRLS 2021 and FUNS 2025 results are comparable measures of the reading crisis.
- •The BELA Act clauses 4 and 5 remain contested within the Government of National Unity.
- •The Department of Basic Education's MTbBE rollout is proceeding as announced.
Limitations
- •FUNS is a new instrument, so trend comparisons over time are limited.
- •Provincial breakdowns of FUNS results were not available in the sources consulted.
- •The analysis does not evaluate individual classroom interventions in detail.
Share
Evaluation Scores
Data Sources
Child literacy: we can change how the story ends (Legal Resources Centre)
report
Reliability: 85%
Accessed: Nov 15, 2026
Celebrating International Mother Language Day (Public Sector Manager, Government of South Africa)
government
Reliability: 85%
Accessed: Nov 15, 2026
